Study Finds AI Assistants Sent Late-Night Toothache Patients to Closed Offices and Dentists Who Could Not Be Found
Seven in ten checkable picks were closed when ChatGPT, Gemini and Claude were asked for an emergency dentist open right
Press Release Disclaimer: This is a press release distributed through the XPR Media network. It has not been independently verified by our newsroom.

![]()
Seven in ten checkable picks were closed when ChatGPT, Gemini and Claude were asked for an emergency dentist open right now in the 50 largest U.S. cities.
SHERIDAN, WY, UNITED STATES, November 16, 2026 /EINPresswire.com/ — At 9:30 on a Saturday night, a patient in Mesa, Arizona, with a bad toothache asks ChatGPT for an emergency dentist who is open right now. One of the three dentists it names is “Dr. Declan Mitchell Emergency Dentist Mesa,” “listed as open 24 hours,” with a phone number and a street address.
Dental.me could find no trace of Dr. Declan Mitchell. There is no Google Maps listing at that name, address or phone number. No dentist by that name appears in the federal National Provider Identifier registry, in Arizona or anywhere else in the country.
Researchers found the same pattern in four more cities.
The finding comes from a new Dental.me study. On Saturday, November 14, 2026, researchers asked the three most popular AI assistants the same question in each of the 50 largest U.S. cities: “I have a bad toothache. I need an emergency dentist in [City] that is open right now. Please name 3 specific dental offices with their phone numbers.” Every place they named was checked against its live Google listing that night.
Key findings
Seven in ten were closed. Of the 248 recommended places whose posted hours could be checked, 170 (69%) were closed at the moment the AI recommended them as open right now. By assistant: ChatGPT 43%, Claude 54% and Gemini 97%. Gemini often named offices that it then said were closed or would open in the morning. 48 of the 50 cities had at least one closed recommendation. In 93 of the 150 answers, not one recommended place could be confirmed open, apart from hospital emergency rooms.
“Open 24 hours,” but closed. The assistants described 201 recommended dental offices as open 24 hours. Only 65 of them could be confirmed open. 46 were closed according to their own Google hours, and 45 could not be found on Google Maps at all.
Dentists who could not be found. 61 recommended places had no Google Maps listing at the name, address or phone number given. 36 of them came from ChatGPT, about one in five of the places it named. Five were named for individual dentists with no record in the federal provider registry in that state. Four of the names belong to no registered dentist anywhere in the country: “Dr. Mark Davidson,” Austin; “Dr. Declan Mitchell,” Mesa; “Dr. Eugene Parker,” Virginia Beach; and “Dr. Hector Sawyer,” Aurora, Colo. The fifth, in Baltimore, carried the name of a dentist registered in another state, and shared its phone number with a second “emergency dentist” listing under a different doctor’s name. Each was described as open 24 hours or available that night.
Not a dentist at all. 112 recommendations were hospital emergency rooms and 70 were hotlines or referral lines. One “emergency dental care” provider recommended in several cities describes itself, in its own online profiles, as a coordination service rather than a dental practice.
“A toothache doesn’t wait for Monday morning, and late at night is exactly when people turn to an AI for help,” said Spencer Whiteclaw, Head Research Analyst at Dental.me. “We asked for a dentist who was open right now, and seven times out of ten the office we could check was closed. Some of the dentists we were sent to could not be found anywhere, not on a map and not in the federal provider registry. When you are in pain at ten o’clock at night, a confident answer that sends you to a locked door, or to a dentist no one can find, is worse than no answer at all. Call before you drive.”
Why it matters
Dental pain rarely waits for business hours. When it strikes at night, many patients now ask an AI assistant instead of searching on their own. This study shows that the answer can send a patient in pain to a closed office, a call center, or a dentist who cannot be found, and often with the confident label “open 24 hours.”
The assistants did add cautions. In 49 of the closed recommendations, the answer itself said the office might be closed or would open in the morning. Gemini in particular often pointed patients to an on-call line or a hospital.
What patients can do at night
Call before you drive. A short call confirms that someone will answer and see you tonight.
Check the office’s own listing or website for tonight’s hours. Do not rely on an “open 24 hours” line in a chat answer.
Be wary of names like “Dr. [Name] Emergency Dentist [City] 24 Hours” with a toll-free number. Ask who will treat you and where.
Go to a hospital emergency room for facial or jaw swelling, fever, or trouble swallowing or breathing. Do not wait for a dentist.
About the study
When: Saturday, November 14, 2026, 10:43 to 11:04 PM Eastern, about 10 PM Central, about 9:30 PM Mountain and 8 to 9 PM Pacific. Every city was asked before local midnight.
Assistants: ChatGPT (chatgpt.com, temporary chat), Google’s Gemini and Anthropic’s Claude, each in a fresh session. 150 answers named 600 places.
Open or closed: judged from each listing’s posted Google hours for that day at the local time asked, not from later status lines. Some offices offer after-hours phone lines; the question asked for an office open right now.
Not found: a place counts as not found only if no Google Maps listing matched the name, address or phone number given. The five dentists named above were also checked against the federal NPI registry and a web search.
Scope: the study measures what AI assistants recommend. It does not evaluate the clinical quality of any practice.
City-by-city results, the full method and free-to-use graphics are on the study page below.
About Dental.me
Dental.me is a national dental directory that scores more than 245,000 U.S. dental practices with the Dental.me Score, a transparent rating built from public records and patient review data, using the same published method for every practice.
Media contact: Spencer Whiteclaw, press@dental.me
For more information, visit Dental.me.
AI emergency dentist study (all 50 cities): https://dental.me/dental-market-data/ai-emergency-dentist-study/
Earlier study, AI dentist recommendations: https://dental.me/dental-market-data/ai-dentist-recommendations/
Dental.me: https://dental.me/
Spencer Whiteclaw
Dental.me
press@dental.me
Legal Disclaimer:
EIN Presswire provides this news content “as is” without warranty of any kind. We do not accept any responsibility or liability
for the accuracy, content, images, videos, licenses, completeness, legality, or reliability of the information contained in this
article. If you have any complaints or copyright issues related to this article, kindly contact the author above.
![]()
Media gallery

